LEISA 20.4
LEISA Magazine • 20.4 • December 2004
Cultivating wetlands in Bangladesh
A. H. M. Rezaul Haq, Tapan Kumar Ghosal and Pritam Ghosh
The village Chandra is situated in the southwest part of Bangladesh on the
banks of the river Kabodak, which flows from Jessore to the Bay of Bengal. In
the past, the 1500 villagers depended on the river for agriculture, aquaculture,
transport and other daily activities. At least 300 villagers had land on the
bank of the river and when the river flooded its banks, silt carried by the
water was deposited on the land, making it fertile and providing the farmers
with good crops. Most of the villagers farmed their land and maintained their
livelihoods in happiness. The village was also famous throughout Bangladesh
for its mango, jackfruit and dates.
In course of time, however, the river became a curse instead of a blessing.
In early 1960s, the then East Pakistan Water and Power Development Authority
engaged in the Coastal Embankment Project (CEP) to convert the seasonally flooded
coastal wetlands into reclaimed land for permanent agricultural production under
the Green Revolution Programme, as well as to protect human settlements from
the floods. This large-scale engineering intervention ignored the agro-ecological
system of the southwest region and disrupted the ecologically complex and highly
productive coastal wetland ecosystem. The reclaimed land is now isolated from
the river and does not receive any silt to improve its fertility. The silt load
is instead deposited in the river, blocking the drainage of the area and leading
to permanent water logging. This situation makes both agriculture and aquaculture
activities impossible. Social demoralization, diseases, unemployment and migration
have increased in the village. The Water Development Board of the Government
has not been able to reduce the waterlogging, which takes over an additional
4000 hectares per year. The view of experts and local people is that there is
no other way out, but to live with water.
Problems in Chandra
The river is fully congested with water hyacinths (Eichhornia crassipes) and
other aquatic weeds and has become a breeding ground for mosquitoes. As the
carrying capacity of the river has been reduced and the drainage system has
broken down, the water level now rises by more than 2.5 metres during the monsoon.
As the flooding stays for 60 - 90 days, trees like mango, jackfruit and date
palm do not survive and the waterlogged lands have not produced any yield for
the past six years. Without food or safe drinking water, villagers have been
forced to migrate elsewhere. The people of Chandra had been seeking an ecologically
sound alternative food production system for their waterlogged areas. To improve
the livelihoods and food security the Wetland Resource Development Society (WRDS),
a voluntary Research and Development organization, proposed soil-less agriculture
as a possible solution for the villagers of Chandra. Considering the regular
flooding every year, the waterlogging, availability of aquatic weeds and the
situation of the landless farmers, this farming system was considered suitable
for the area and capable of high agricultural production. Today WRDS is implementing
soil-less agriculture in waterlogged areas of the south west region of Bangladesh
under the project of CARE-RVCC (Reducing Vulnerability to Climate Change), funded
by CIDA (Canadian International Development Agency).
Soil-less agriculture
Soil-less agriculture or hydroponics (a Greek word, hydro means water and ponos
means labour) is an indigenous practice of sustainable wetland utilization in
parts of south-west Bangladesh. People living within the wetland ecosystem utilize
locally available paddy straw, water hyacinths and various aquatic plants for
making floating islands of organic material on which crops, seedlings and vegetables
are grown. The productivity of this farming system is more or less 10 times
higher than traditional land-based agricultural production. This farming system
is locally known as baira, geto, bed or dhap. After cultivation, the remains
of the floating organic bed is rich in nutrients and make good compost. This
farming system is labour intensive and offers opportunities for the participation
of men as well as women.
The benefits of hydroponics
Making waterlogged areas productive
Bangladesh, being an overpopulated country, can ill afford to depend only on
its ever-shrinking areas of arable land to feed the population. Wetlands, including
waterlogged areas, have been seen as crisis regions, as no terrestrial crops
would grow there. A number of projects have been undertaken by the government
and NGOs since the 1960s to increase agricultural production by controlling
flooding and draining the wetlands. However, these projects have adversely affected
both the economy and the environment. Soil-less cultivation can help to mitigate
this crisis and reduce the pressure on arable lands by turning wetlands into
a strong base for the rural economy, without altering the natural environment.
Conserving water and nutrients
A properly designed hydroponic system needs much less water and nutrients than
conventional soil-based agriculture, as the nutrients are recycled. This advantage
is important as it can help in reducing the pollution of water bodies with the
high level of runoff nutrients from agricultural land. In addition, an enormous
amount of compost material is produced, which can be used to increase the organic
content of the soil for land-based agriculture systems. Compost selling could
potentially be a good opportunity for income generation, as soil degradation
due to loss of organic matter is significant in Bangladesh.
Conserving biodiversity
The present waterlogged areas can, over time, be turned into productive wetlands
because of their biodiversity and the abundance of various kinds of highly productive
aquatic vegetation, fish, aquatic organisms and birds. For example, hydroponics
can have a positive impact on open water fisheries by reducing weed congestion
and using nutrients in the water. This biodiversity, if properly managed, could
contribute to revitalizing the rural economy, particularly for the poorer sections
of the community.
The villagers of Chandra did not know about this farming technique. When this
type of cultivation was first proposed, it made them laugh – they could
not believe that it could be possible to cultivate on water! After receiving
training and technical support on soil-less agriculture, more than 150 villagers
started to practise this type of non-conventional agriculture on their waterlogged
areas adjacent to the river Kabodak. After some practice, the villagers realized
that cultivation on floating beds could give higher production as well as a
better costbenefit ratio than land-based agriculture. A renaissance occurred
among the villagers of Chandra.
Construction of floating beds
The basic construction of the floating bed requires bamboo poles, a boat and
a simple tool to cut the weeds. The bed is then built up of layers of aquatic
weeds, mainly water hyacinths (Eichhornia crassipes) but also other kinds of
water weeds like water lettuce (Pistia stratiotes), duckweed (Najas graminea),
Salvinia spp. and Potamogeton alpinus. Organic materials like paddy stubs, straw
and coconut husk are also added. In perennial wetlands and permanently waterlogged
areas it is possible to cultivate on these floating beds the whole year round.
In seasonally waterlogged areas, the beds are used during the wet season and
left to decompose on the agricultural land once the water withdraws. The floating
beds are primarily constructed where water hyacinths are available. The beds
can be prepared in any depth of water and they can be moved by dragging them
behind a boat.
In Chandra, the villagers construct floating beds using the masses of water
hyacinths and other aquatic weeds that grow naturally and profusely in the river,
surrounding wetlands, canals and ditches. Construction starts at the beginning
of the monsoon (June-July) with the collection of water hyacinths and other
aquatic weeds and it continues up to late autumn. To start the construction,
farmers put a long bamboo pole (as long as they want the final bed to be), on
a collected mass of fully matured water hyacinths. To build one bed, water hyacinths
growing in an area roughly five times larger than the bed itself are required.
Mature water hyacinths are preferred because they decompose slower than immature
water hyacinths. The first layer of water hyacinths acts as the base of the
floating bed and maintains the stability, buoyancy and thickness of the bed.
A single man then stands on the bamboo pole lying over the mass of water hyacinths
and starts to pull the water hyacinths together from both sides of the bamboo.
In this process, he proceeds towards the end of the bamboo and compacts the
accumulated hyacinths under his feet. This process is continued until the desired
height and length of the bed is obtained. When the construction of the bed is
complete, the bamboo is removed. After 7 - 10 days a second round of water hyacinths
are dumped on the bed and then the bed is left to decompose before being planted.
The top of the floating bed needs 15 - 20 days to decompose before sowing seed
or planting seedlings. Sometimes farmers use semi-decomposed aquatic plants
such as water lettuce, duckweed and immature water hyacinths on the top of the
bed to speed up the decomposition, thereby making nutrients available for seedlings
and reducing evaporation from the bed. To improve conditions for the young seedlings
further, the seeds are sometimes placed inside a ball made of compost, manure
and aquatic creepers (locally called tema), before being planted on the floating
bed. In this way, a smooth germination and sufficient nutrients are ensured
for the initial establishment. However, the newly constructed floating bed can
also be cultivated from the first day – if compost is available and is
spread thickly on the bed before planting.
There are no fixed rules about the size and shape of the floating beds, but
generally the villagers construct beds that are 15 - 50 metres in length, 1.5
- 2.5 metres in width and about one metre in height above the water level.
Crops and vegetables
Vegetables are the main crops of this farming system. The villagers have grown
23 different types of vegetables and 5 types of spices. Vegetables and seedlings
raised on floating beds during the monsoon season include ladies finger (okra),
cucumber, ridged gourd, bitter gourd, snake gourd, amaranth, red amaranth, egg
plant (brinjal), pumpkin, Indian spinach, taro, wax gourd, and turmeric. During
the winter season spinach, bottle gourd, yard long bean, bean, tomato, potato,
cauliflower, cabbage, kohlrabi, turnip, radish, carrot, ginger, onion, chilli,
and garlic are grown. Some vegetables are grown on the bed all the year round,
in rotation. In seasonally flooded areas, the beds are spread over the soil
as the water withdraws. Winter crops can then be grown on this soil without
further tillage or fertilizer.
Conclusion
Bangladesh has the highest wetland to total land ratio in the world: Almost
half of the area of Bangladesh consists of wetlands. Bangladesh also has an
excessive population growth, leading to increasing pressure on agricultural
land as well as an increasing number of people that are landless. To increase
the agricultural production, high yielding varieties together with fertilizers
and pesticides have been introduced. However, this production system is cost
intensive and has led to negative environmental consequences. Today, yields
are stagnating. In addition, in some areas of Bangladesh drastic water regulation
projects have reclaimed land to allow continuous cultivation of high-yielding
varieties. These drastic changes have had large negative environmental effects
and in some areas, like Chandra, have had devastating environmental consequences.
At the same time, soil-less cultivation has existed for more than 250 years
in parts of Bangladesh’s wetlands. The system has proven itself to be
highly productive and ecologically sound, but is only practised to a limited
extent, in around 2500 hectares. In the south-west region of Bangladesh there
exists about 200 000 hectares of natural and artificial wetlands. Of this, about
20 000 hectares could potentially be used for of soil-less agriculture.
The WRDS has realized the potential of soil-less cultivation and is promoting
it as an alternative in new areas such as Chandra, where the villagers now see
the aquatic weeds as blessing and a resource. The number of farmers that are
cultivating on floating beds is increasing at a significant rate in and around
the village. As the system is fully organic, the agricultural products from
the floating beds get special attention from the local buyers and consumers.
The local community is therefore very hopeful that they will be able to improve
their condition through rapidly increasing production from this farming system
in their waterlogged areas. The lost happiness is returning among the villagers
of Chandra.
A. H. M. Rezaul Haq,Tapan Kumar Ghosal and Pritam
Ghosh. WRDS, 21, Hazi Mohsin Road, Khulna-9100, Bangladesh. Email:
wrds@bttb.net.bd, wetland@bttb.net.bd
References
- Haq, A.H.M. Rezaul; M. Asaduzzaman, and T. K. Ghosal, 2002. Soil-less agriculture
in Bangladesh. 111 p. A Grameen Trust, Bangladesh Publication under the component
of Research for Poverty Alleviation. Grameen Bank Bhaban, Mirpur 2, Dhaka 1216.
Email: g-trust@grameen.com
- Resh, H. M., 1981. Hydroponic food production. Published by Woodbridge Press
Publishing Company, Santa Barbara, California.